In The Concept of Miracle, Richard Swinburne (RS) examines Humean arguments against miracles[i] and finds them wanting. His modest goal in this book is not to argue for the truth of miracles, but rather to defend the possibility of justified belief in the miraculous. He approaches this goal by rebutting anti-miraculous Humean arguments and discussing criteria which, if met, would ground justified belief in the occurrence of a miracle.
As with any work of Swinburne’s, even a short book like this one (a mere 71 pages) has plenty of ‘meat’ to be slowly digested, and plenty of links between earlier and later material. This presents a reviewer with a decision—to follow RS closely, or to restructure to make what seem to be the central points clearer. I’ve chosen the latter approach.
Saturday, January 17, 2015
Book Review: The Concept of Miracle by Richard Swinburne
Topics:
apologetics
,
Book Reviews
,
Miracles
,
Richard Swinburne
Friday, January 16, 2015
Weekly Apologetics Bonus Links (01/09- 01/16)
Here are this week's recommended apologetics links. Enjoy.
KINDLE DEALS:
• Five Views on Apologetics - 2.99
• God Under Fire - 1.99
• Think Christianly by Jonathan Morrow - 1.99
• The Love of Wisdom: A Christian Introduction to Philosopy - 0.99
• 20 Compelling Evidences That God Exists by Bowman & Boa FREE - GREAT book
• Worldview Conversations: How to Share Your Faith and Keep Your Friends - 2.99
• Christ Files: How Historians Know What They Know about Jesus by John Dickson - 1.99
• Finding the Real Jesus: A Guide for Curious Christians and Skeptical Seekers by Lee Strobel - 1.99
WEEKLY LINKS:
• Short Answers to Big Questions
• Immersion - Impact 360 Institute
• John Lennox on Intelligent Design
• RZIM Canada Summer School 2015
• R.C. Sproul on the Task of Apologetics
• An Interview with Brian Auten of Apologetics315
• God, Science & The Big Questions January 30th
• What is the Oldest Manuscript of the New Testament?
• Video: What Do You Mean by Evolution? by Frank Turek
• 3 Things You Can Do to Encourage Apologetics in Your Church
• Why does God let people suffer? Why is there so much evil in the world?
Apologetics 315 is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit. Would you support us?
• Five Views on Apologetics - 2.99
• God Under Fire - 1.99
• Think Christianly by Jonathan Morrow - 1.99
• The Love of Wisdom: A Christian Introduction to Philosopy - 0.99
• 20 Compelling Evidences That God Exists by Bowman & Boa FREE - GREAT book
• Worldview Conversations: How to Share Your Faith and Keep Your Friends - 2.99
• Christ Files: How Historians Know What They Know about Jesus by John Dickson - 1.99
• Finding the Real Jesus: A Guide for Curious Christians and Skeptical Seekers by Lee Strobel - 1.99
WEEKLY LINKS:
• Short Answers to Big Questions
• Immersion - Impact 360 Institute
• John Lennox on Intelligent Design
• RZIM Canada Summer School 2015
• R.C. Sproul on the Task of Apologetics
• An Interview with Brian Auten of Apologetics315
• God, Science & The Big Questions January 30th
• What is the Oldest Manuscript of the New Testament?
• Video: What Do You Mean by Evolution? by Frank Turek
• 3 Things You Can Do to Encourage Apologetics in Your Church
• Why does God let people suffer? Why is there so much evil in the world?
Apologetics 315 is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit. Would you support us?
• Shopping via Amazon? If you use this link, a bit of your purchase goes to fund Apologetics 315. Thanks for those of you using the link, as it helps Ap315.
Canada here. UK here.
• Would you like to help with interview transcription? If so, contact Ap315 here.
Get these sorts of links and more by following on Twitter.Canada here. UK here.
• Would you like to help with interview transcription? If so, contact Ap315 here.
For daily post links, please follow on Facebook.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Bonus Links
Thursday, January 15, 2015
"That's Just Your Opinion" by Greg Koukl
Greg Koukl of Stand to Reason shares how to respond when someone says, "That's just you're opinion" when you're sharing your faith. For more videos by STR, check out their YouTube Channel here. Enjoy.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Greg Koukl
,
Videos
Wednesday, January 14, 2015
The Atheist Manual—MP3: Tim McGrew & Tom Gilson
This audio is from the The Defend the Faith Conference, held January 4-9, 2015 on the campus of New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary. The event was organized by ICA, and streamed and recorded by Tactical Faith, and had scores of lectures in apologetics and evangelism by some great apologists. (Tactical Faith past events lectures can be found here.) Watch this blog post for information on accessing all the talks from the event.
In this lecture, Dr. Timothy McGrew and Tom Gilson discuss the tactics and content of Peter Boghossian's book A Manual for Creating Atheists, offering an analysis and critique.
Full Lecture MP3 Audio here (1hr)
Enjoy.
In this lecture, Dr. Timothy McGrew and Tom Gilson discuss the tactics and content of Peter Boghossian's book A Manual for Creating Atheists, offering an analysis and critique.
Enjoy.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Atheism
,
audio
,
conferences
,
mp3
,
Tactical Faith
,
Tim McGrew
,
Tom Gilson
Tuesday, January 13, 2015
Terminology Tuesday: Inference
Inference: In everyday usage, when people speak of an inference they sometimes mean a 'guess' based on the information they have, or the conclusion they have reached - again, based on other things they believe. For example, after reviewing the evidence a detective might say, 'The inference is that we should question Jones again about this case.' In our context, the usage is derived from logic, where it means the 'step' from reasons to conclusion, the 'move' from one to the other. Thus, if someone argues, 'Some people have solved their own unemployment problem by great ingenuity in searching for a job or by willingness to work for less so all the unemployed could do this', the inference is the move from 'some people have...' to 'all the unemployed could do this'. Though the reason presented in this argument has often been true, the inference to the argument's conclusion is much more questionable.11. Alec Fisher, Critical Thinking: An Introduction
Topics:
apologetics
,
terminology
Monday, January 12, 2015
Apologist Interview: Graham Veale
Today's interview is with Graham Veale, author of New Atheism: A Survival Guide, and he a co-founder and writer at saintsandsceptics.org. He talks about religious education, the resources at the blog, the influence of the atheist movement, atheism amongst students, the arguments in his book, the "flying spaghetti monster," the non-conflict between Christianity and science, the rhetorical strategy of the new atheists, the biggest strengths and weaknesses of the new atheism, the centrality of Christ in apologetics & evangelism, and more.
Full Interview MP3 Audio here (45 min)
Enjoy.
Subscribe to the Apologetics 315 Interviews podcast here or in iTunes.
Full Interview MP3 Audio here (45 min)
Enjoy.
Subscribe to the Apologetics 315 Interviews podcast here or in iTunes.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Apologist Interviews
,
Atheism
,
Graham Veale
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Sunday Quote: Frank Tipler on Cosmology
"When I began my career as a cosmologist some twenty years ago, I was a convinced atheist. I never in my wildest dreams imagined that one day I would be writing a book purporting to show that the central claims of Judeo-Christian theology are in fact true, that these claims are straightforward deductions of the laws of physics as we now understand them. I have been forced into these conclusions by the inexorable logic of my own special branch of physics."- Frank Tipler
(The Physics of Immortality, Doubleday, New York, 1994, Preface)
Topics:
Cosmology
,
Frank Tipler
,
Quotes
Saturday, January 10, 2015
Book Review: Seriously Dangerous Religion: What the Old Testament Really Says and Why It Matters
I had lunch today with two friends, both of whom are involved in apologetics ministries. We discussed the biggest weakness among evangelical apologetics—theology—particularly biblical theology. Apologists are too typically ignorant of the Bible and the theology grounded in it. We can discuss the latest articles in philosophy and science, but become very shaky discussing the Bible. The reasons are many, but this general ignorance compounds when the focus shifts to the Old Testament in particular.
Consider how many apologetic conversations you’ve had recently about the Old Testament. They probably focused on Creation or the conquest narratives in Joshua. Now consider how much of those discussions actually considered the Old Testament passages. If the conversations were like most, then they quickly framed the discussions in terms of science, philosophy and ethics—all fields where modern apologists are more comfortable. Here’s the problem…our apologetics should be be saturated with Scripture, at least in how it frames our discussions.[1] We are not generic theists, but Christians.[2] I believe that a general ignorance of the Bible, and especially the Old Testament only hurts apologists.
Consider how many apologetic conversations you’ve had recently about the Old Testament. They probably focused on Creation or the conquest narratives in Joshua. Now consider how much of those discussions actually considered the Old Testament passages. If the conversations were like most, then they quickly framed the discussions in terms of science, philosophy and ethics—all fields where modern apologists are more comfortable. Here’s the problem…our apologetics should be be saturated with Scripture, at least in how it frames our discussions.[1] We are not generic theists, but Christians.[2] I believe that a general ignorance of the Bible, and especially the Old Testament only hurts apologists.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Book Reviews
,
Old Testament
Friday, January 09, 2015
Weekly Apologetics Bonus Links (01/02- 01/09)
Here are this week's recommended apologetics links. Enjoy.
KINDLE DEALS:
• Worldview Conversations: How to Share Your Faith and Keep Your Friends - 2.99
• Five Views on Apologetics - 2.99
• Saving Leonardo by Nancy Pearcey - 2.99
• The Love of Wisdom: A Christian Introduction to Philosopy - 0.99
• True for You, But Not for Me by Paul Copan - 1.99
• Worldviews in Conflict by Ronald H. Nash - 4.68
• The End of Christianity by William Dembski - 0.99
• 20 Compelling Evidences That God Exists by Bowman & Boa FREE - GREAT book
• Finding the Real Jesus: A Guide for Curious Christians and Skeptical Seekers by Lee Strobel - 1.99
WEEKLY LINKS:
• AMP Conference 2015
• 10 Things Science cannot do
• 5 Ways to Preach Apologetically
• The Bible Is Not a Game of Telephone
• New 9-part DVD SERIES from Frank Turek
• Dr. William Lane Craig at Rutgers University
• Sharing Your Faith With Mormons Conference UK
• How to Have a Conversation About Bible Contradictions
• Book Giveaway: Joseph Smith's Tritheism by Dayton Hartman
• Are you Skeptical of the Bible Because it Reports Miracles?
• Defending the Faith Conference LIVE STREAM by Tactical Faith
Apologetics 315 is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit. Would you support us?
• Worldview Conversations: How to Share Your Faith and Keep Your Friends - 2.99
• Five Views on Apologetics - 2.99
• Saving Leonardo by Nancy Pearcey - 2.99
• The Love of Wisdom: A Christian Introduction to Philosopy - 0.99
• True for You, But Not for Me by Paul Copan - 1.99
• Worldviews in Conflict by Ronald H. Nash - 4.68
• The End of Christianity by William Dembski - 0.99
• 20 Compelling Evidences That God Exists by Bowman & Boa FREE - GREAT book
• Finding the Real Jesus: A Guide for Curious Christians and Skeptical Seekers by Lee Strobel - 1.99
WEEKLY LINKS:
• AMP Conference 2015
• 10 Things Science cannot do
• 5 Ways to Preach Apologetically
• The Bible Is Not a Game of Telephone
• New 9-part DVD SERIES from Frank Turek
• Dr. William Lane Craig at Rutgers University
• Sharing Your Faith With Mormons Conference UK
• How to Have a Conversation About Bible Contradictions
• Book Giveaway: Joseph Smith's Tritheism by Dayton Hartman
• Are you Skeptical of the Bible Because it Reports Miracles?
• Defending the Faith Conference LIVE STREAM by Tactical Faith
Apologetics 315 is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit. Would you support us?
• Shopping via Amazon? If you use this link, a bit of your purchase goes to fund Apologetics 315. Thanks for those of you using the link, as it helps Ap315.
Canada here. UK here.
• Would you like to help with interview transcription? If so, contact Ap315 here.
Get these sorts of links and more by following on Twitter.Canada here. UK here.
• Would you like to help with interview transcription? If so, contact Ap315 here.
For daily post links, please follow on Facebook.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Bonus Links
Thursday, January 08, 2015
The New Apostolic Reformation - Doug Geivett MP3 Audio
In this audio from the Janet Mefferd show, Doug Geivett, professor of philosophy in the Talbot School of Theology at Biola University, is interviewed on the topic of the movement called "The New Apolostolic Reformation" (NAR). What should Christians make of this widespread modern-day claim that new apostles and prophets walk among us? He discusses his new book: A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement. Other resources by Doug Geivett here. Find his blog here.
Full Interview MP3 Audio here. (37 minutes)
Enjoy.
Full Interview MP3 Audio here. (37 minutes)
Enjoy.
Topics:
apologetics
,
audio
,
Douglas Geivett
,
Interview
,
mp3
,
theology
Wednesday, January 07, 2015
Answering Doubts: A Conference for Questions—Videos
The videos from the 2014 RZIM "Answering Doubts" Conference is now online. Designed as "a gathering for Christians and non-Christians alike focused on addressing essential, profound, and relevant questions about the Christian worldview," this conference featured talks and Q&A forums with featured speakers Nabeel Quereshi, Cameron McAllister, and Alycia Wood. All videos one page here. Or view on YouTube here:
• Is Christianity Beautiful? - Cameron McAllister
• The Problem of Truth - Alycia Wood
• Can We Know if God is Real? - Nabeel Qureshi
• Media and the Gospel - Cameron McAllister
• Why Do I Need God? - Alycia Wood
• My Journey to Christ - Nabeel Qureshi
• Answering Doubts Q&A #1
Enjoy.
• Is Christianity Beautiful? - Cameron McAllister
• The Problem of Truth - Alycia Wood
• Can We Know if God is Real? - Nabeel Qureshi
• Media and the Gospel - Cameron McAllister
• Why Do I Need God? - Alycia Wood
• My Journey to Christ - Nabeel Qureshi
• Answering Doubts Q&A #1
Enjoy.
Topics:
apologetics
,
conferences
,
Nabeel Qureshi
,
Videos
Tuesday, January 06, 2015
Terminology Tuesday: Time, Timelessness
Time, Timelessness: Time refers to the relation of events within creation to each other. Generally events are viewed as forming a linear succession, leading to the idea of the "time line." But the succession of events might also by cyclical, resulting in time as a circle. The Bible presents time as a divinely created reality in which God historically works out the divine plan of salvation. Thus time begins "in the beginning" and moves linearly toward a future goal. Philosophers and theologians have debated how time and eternity are related, as well as the nature of the connection between God and time. Some thinkers assert that time and eternity are totally distinct, while others collapse them, in part as a reaction against viewing time itself being an entity. Theologians who assert that God is timeless maintain that God created time and therefore stands "above" the temporal flow. Others suggest that God travels with creation through time.1Suggested reading on God & time:
• Time and Eternity: Exploring God's Relationship to Time
• God & Time: Four Views
1. Stanley J. Grenz, David Guretzki & Cherith Fee Nordling, Pocket Dictionary of Theological Terms (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1999), p. 115.
Topics:
apologetics
,
terminology
Monday, January 05, 2015
Apologist Interview: Dr. Jefrey Breshears
Today’s interview is with Dr. Jefrey Breshears, Christian historian, apologist, the president of "The Areopagus” and author of An Introduction to Bibliology. He talks about his background and interest in history and apologetics, the problem of anti-intellectualism in the church (and what can be done about it), the systematic study of the bible (bibliology), an overview of An Introduction to Bibliology, bad arguments for the Bible, good arguments for the Bible, defending the inspiration of scripture, how we got the books that are in the Bible (the canon), the transmission of the Biblical texts, the significance of textual variants, answering skeptics regarding apparent contradictions, the most misunderstood issues about the Bible, and more.
Full Interview MP3 Audio here (37 min)
Enjoy.
Subscribe to the Apologetics 315 Interviews podcast here or in iTunes.
Full Interview MP3 Audio here (37 min)
Enjoy.
Subscribe to the Apologetics 315 Interviews podcast here or in iTunes.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Apologist Interviews
,
Bible
,
canon
,
History
,
Jefrey Breshears
Sunday, January 04, 2015
Jaroslav Pelikan on Christian Education
"The church is always more than a school…. But the church cannot be less than a school."
— Jaroslav Pelikan
The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition (100-600) (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1971), 1.
— Jaroslav Pelikan
The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition (100-600) (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1971), 1.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Jaroslav Pelikan
,
Quotes
Saturday, January 03, 2015
Book Review: The Doors of the Sea: Where was God in the Tsunami?
David Bentley Hart’s essay The Doors of the Sea: Where was God in the Tsunami? is a delightful little book in many ways. It is very well-written, and it has some provocative and often helpful things to say about theodicy. One of the things that is most interesting about this book is that Hart spends at least as much time (maybe even more time) speaking of what we might call “meta-theodicy” as he does in developing a theodicy proper. That is, he has as much to say about when, where, and in what circumstances theodicy is appropriate, and about what general approach the Christian should take to theodicy, as he does about the particular theodicy that he wishes to defend. This reviewer actually found these portions of the essay more engaging than much of Hart’s own theodicizing!
Topics:
apologetics
,
Book Reviews
,
David Bentley Hart
,
Problem of Evil
,
suffering
Friday, January 02, 2015
Weekly Apologetics Bonus Links (12/26 - 01/02)
Here are this week's recommended apologetics links. Enjoy.
KINDLE DEALS:
• When the Lights Go Down: Movie Review as Christian Practice - 3.03
• Worldview Conversations: How to Share Your Faith and Keep Your Friends - 2.99
• Five Views on Apologetics - 2.99
• Saving Leonardo by Nancy Pearcey - 2.99
• Mere Apologetics by Alister McGrath - 2.99
• The Love of Wisdom: A Christian Introduction to Philosopy - 0.99
• Come Let Us Reason: New Essays in Christian Apologetics - 0.99
WEEKLY LINKS:
• Do atheists have a burden of proof?
• Online Webinar with Greg Koukl
• God, Science & The Big Questions at Biola University
• Advice to Christian Apologists from William Lane Craig
• The Top Ten 2014 Cold Case Christianity Broadcasts
• Scholars Respond to Newsweek's Misrepresentation of the Bible
• Lee Strobel, Colleagues at HBU Launch Center for American Evangelism, Hope to Address Crisis of Skepticism
Apologetics 315 is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit. Would you support us?
• When the Lights Go Down: Movie Review as Christian Practice - 3.03
• Worldview Conversations: How to Share Your Faith and Keep Your Friends - 2.99
• Five Views on Apologetics - 2.99
• Saving Leonardo by Nancy Pearcey - 2.99
• Mere Apologetics by Alister McGrath - 2.99
• The Love of Wisdom: A Christian Introduction to Philosopy - 0.99
• Come Let Us Reason: New Essays in Christian Apologetics - 0.99
WEEKLY LINKS:
• Do atheists have a burden of proof?
• Online Webinar with Greg Koukl
• God, Science & The Big Questions at Biola University
• Advice to Christian Apologists from William Lane Craig
• The Top Ten 2014 Cold Case Christianity Broadcasts
• Scholars Respond to Newsweek's Misrepresentation of the Bible
• Lee Strobel, Colleagues at HBU Launch Center for American Evangelism, Hope to Address Crisis of Skepticism
Apologetics 315 is a registered 501(c)(3) non-profit. Would you support us?
• Shopping via Amazon? If you use this link, a bit of your purchase goes to fund Apologetics 315. Thanks for those of you using the link, as it helps Ap315.
Canada here. UK here.
• Would you like to help with interview transcription? If so, contact Ap315 here.
Get these sorts of links and more by following on Twitter.Canada here. UK here.
• Would you like to help with interview transcription? If so, contact Ap315 here.
For daily post links, please follow on Facebook.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Bonus Links
Confessions of a Former Atheist
In this audio, found on William Lane Craig's Reasonable Faith Podcast, former atheist Peter Byrom shares some of the details of his interaction with Richard Dawkins and his journey from atheism to Christianity. You can subscribe to the Reasonable Faith podcast here.
Full MP3 Audio file here. (20 minutes)
Enjoy.
Full MP3 Audio file here. (20 minutes)
Enjoy.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Atheism
,
Richard Dawkins
,
William Lane Craig
Thursday, January 01, 2015
Introducing the Center for American Evangelism
Introducing the Center for American Evangelism at Houston Baptist University. Lee Strobel, Mark Mittelberg and Garry Poole, and under the leadership of HBU President Dr. Robert B. Sloan, Jr., are launching an exciting new initiative to address the challenges facing Christianity in America.
Their mission is to bring leadership, vision, innovation, and training to students, pastors, church leaders, and congregations throughout our nation, to help us all regain our focus and passion for fulfilling the Great Commission (Matt. 28:18-20). They aim to accomplish this through numerous strategic efforts: forums for pastors; classes for students; conferences and seminars for church leaders; simulcasts to churches; newsletters and social media; and new curricula that will bring fresh vision and training to Christians and churches all over America.
Learn more about the Center for American Evangelism here.
You can also support them here.
Their mission is to bring leadership, vision, innovation, and training to students, pastors, church leaders, and congregations throughout our nation, to help us all regain our focus and passion for fulfilling the Great Commission (Matt. 28:18-20). They aim to accomplish this through numerous strategic efforts: forums for pastors; classes for students; conferences and seminars for church leaders; simulcasts to churches; newsletters and social media; and new curricula that will bring fresh vision and training to Christians and churches all over America.
Learn more about the Center for American Evangelism here.
You can also support them here.
Topics:
apologetics
,
Evangelism
,
Lee Strobel
,
Mark Mittelberg
Tuesday, December 30, 2014
Terminology Tuesday: Imply/Implication
Imply/Implication: There is an everyday sense of these words which means roughly, 'suggests' or 'leads me to believe', as when the detective says, 'the evidence implies that Smith was present at the murder'. However, the word 'imply' is often used more strictly to mean 'if ... then ...' For example, if someone says, 'the presence of fire implies that there must be oxygen present', they could equally well say, 'if there is fire then oxygen must be present'. In general, to say that 'A implies B' is to say something like 'if A then B', either strictly as in the oxygen example or more loosely as in the detective example. To say that 'A entails B' is usually to say 'A implies B' in this strict usage of 'implies'.11. Alec Fisher, Critical Thinking: An Introduction
Topics:
apologetics
,
terminology
Thursday, December 25, 2014
Merry Christmas from Apologetics 315
Tuesday, December 23, 2014
Terminology Tuesday: Inclusivism
Inclusivism: A theory of salvation that suggests that although God saves people only on the merits of Christ, not all who are saved have consciously known of Jesus or heard the gospel. God saves those who, although they have not heard of Jesus, nevertheless respond to the best of their knowledge to the revelation of God available to them. This view stands in contrast to both exclusivism, which suggests that God saves only those who consciously respond to the presentation of the gospel of Jesus Christ, and to pluralism, which sees saving value in non-Christian religions.11. Stanley J. Grenz, David Guretzki & Cherith Fee Nordling, Pocket Dictionary of Theological Terms (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1999), p. 65.
Topics:
apologetics
,
terminology











